Authenticity vs AI in Modern Marketing
Apple's handmade glass logo was applauded and Coca-Cola's AI Santa was slammed, and the gap between them says a lot about where marketing is heading.

TL;DR
Audiences are turning against AI-generated ads: Apple's handmade glass Apple TV intro was applauded, while Coca-Cola's AI Christmas ad drew more than 30,000 negative comments. Human craft still wins in emotional storytelling, so use AI for ideas and versioning and keep human judgment and craft where trust matters.
AI-generated ads are struggling to win audiences over, while campaigns that show real human craft are being rewarded. People increasingly value authenticity over efficiency, and effort over automation.
The creative industry just got a wake-up call. In the same week, Apple released a handcrafted Apple TV intro built from real glass with no CGI, and Coca-Cola dropped an AI-made Christmas ad that audiences instantly disliked. One campaign was applauded for its craft. The other was mocked for cutting corners. The lesson for marketers goes well beyond Christmas storytelling.
Why did Apple's handmade ad beat Coca-Cola's AI ad?
Apple's five-second Apple TV intro was made entirely by hand. The team at Media Arts Lab and Optical Arts built a glass Apple logo, lit it with colour and filmed every shimmer in-camera. The reveal video on YouTube drew over a million organic views in 72 hours, with industry peers praising its restraint and realism.
It's a bold move at a time when 94 percent of brands globally say they're testing AI-generated creativity. Instead of automation, Apple leaned into tangibility, and it paid off. A WARC analysis found that campaigns using practical craft or physical sets deliver 27 percent higher long-term brand lift than fully digital productions. Craft signals effort, and audiences reward effort.
Coca-Cola went the other way. Its 2025 Christmas campaign, built with generative AI, featured an uncanny AI Santa and glitching winter scenes. Within days, the ad drew over 30,000 negative comments, and engagement fell 42 percent below the previous year's live-action version, according to Brandwatch data.
In the UK, where Christmas ads are treated as the Super Bowl of emotional storytelling, the contrast is stark. John Lewis's 2023 campaign, shot practically with a single animatronic Venus flytrap, reached 84 percent positive sentiment and lifted brand favourability by 7 points, its highest in five years. Authenticity isn't nostalgia. It's performance.
Why are audiences looking for authenticity?
1. Trust has fractured. After years of algorithmic feeds, consumers are sceptical. NielsenIQ research found that 64 percent of viewers can identify AI-made ads, and they trust them 25 percent less than human-made ones. In B2C categories like FMCG and retail, perceived authenticity now drives up to two-thirds of brand loyalty.
2. Emotion takes effort. A peer-reviewed study in the Journal of Business Research found that when people believe emotional messages are AI-generated, they feel moral discomfort and rate the brand as manipulative. Genuine storytelling still relies on human rhythm, empathy and imperfection, which algorithms replicate poorly.
3. Authenticity earns attention. Neuroscience-based ad testing by System1 Group found that viewers spend 23 percent more time watching work that shows visible human craft, such as hand-drawn elements, physical props or real settings, than synthetic visuals. The brain reads effort as a social signal and rewards perceived craftsmanship with higher engagement.
4. "Real" feels scarce again. When everything is instant and auto-generated, the handmade becomes premium. Marketers are seeing a "re-humanisation effect", where tangible experiences like an artisan product, a handwritten card or a live-shot video beat automated ones on recall and sentiment.
What can marketers learn?
For creative teams
Human craft still beats automation in emotional storytelling. Use AI for ideation or versioning, not as the final voice. If your brand positioning depends on trust, emotion or nostalgia, avoid generative imagery altogether. Craft builds memory structures, and memory drives long-term ROI.
For performance marketers
AI can optimise campaigns, but it can't connect with hearts. Test human-made creative separately from machine-generated versions. Across multiple meta-analyses, creative quality explains 47 percent of the variance in campaign ROI, while targeting explains just 9 percent. Put storytelling and distinctiveness first, because algorithms can't fix weak ideas.
For brand strategists
Authenticity is now measurable. Kantar's 2024 BrandZ data shows brands seen as "authentic" grow market share 2.5 times faster than those seen as "efficient" or "innovative". Your differentiator may not be technology. It may be truthfulness.
Is craft making a comeback?
Audiences have hit saturation point. The internet is full of content but thin on meaning. Apple's five-second glass logo worked because it felt human. Coca-Cola's AI Santa failed because it didn't.
The lesson is clear: people don't just buy products. They buy stories they believe were made by people. The next creative advantage won't go to whoever automates fastest. It will go to whoever uses technology wisely, keeping human judgment, taste and craft where they matter most.
If your brand runs on trust and emotion, real footage of real people still does the heavy lifting, and that's what our videography team is for. Because in marketing, as in life, real still works best. Get in touch if you'd like to talk about your next campaign.
References
- Loyola, R. (2025, November 6). Apple TV's new glassy intro wasn't created on a Mac. Macworld.
- Foley, J. (2025, November 5). Coca-Cola's AI ad just ruined Christmas... again. Creative Bloq.
- Vainilavičius, J. (2025, November 7). New Apple TV intro is all human work. Cybernews.
- NielsenIQ. (2025, September 8). Study reveals hidden consumer views on AI-generated ads. NIQ.
- Kirk, C. P., & Givi, J. (2024). The AI-authorship effect: Understanding authenticity, moral disgust, and consumer responses to AI-generated marketing communications. Journal of Business Research, 186, 114984.
Want a hand with this?
Our Auckland team does Videography for New Zealand businesses every day.
- AI
- Advertising
- Authenticity
- Creative




